Call us today for a free
initial consultation

0800 678 1988

  • I found Salim and the teams approach to be efficient, courteous, helpful and refreshing, especially in pro-active discussion on strategy. I have no hesitation in saying, after two decades of personal experience I couldnít recommend them highly enoughí

    Mike Holborn, Chairman of Ability International Ltd

  • Iíve always found their service to be efficient, yet with that personal touch and attention to detail which builds client confidence and makes the whole team a pleasure to deal with. Their focus is always to add value to the client

    Andy Millar, Managing Director of Woodacre Developments Limited

  • Recommended by a friend in November 2013, AE Finance Ltd now handles both of my company and personal accounts and tax returns. Salim and his team provide not only a great value for money, but most importantly (and rare!) an exceptional level ....

    Kelly Oliver, Project Director, Alethia Media Ltd

  • AE Finance Ltd have helped me in many areas of business through some unusual situations, in a warm and friendly and professional manner with advice and help whenever necessary. I have received wonderful support and help from all the team at AE Finance Ltd....

    Tracey Walker, Managing Director of Home & Garden Care Limited

  • I would like to commend AE Finance Ltd for all their help and advice over the last nine years. They have provided a very proactive, professional and courteous service with our Company Accounts, Payroll and Personal Taxation.....

    Steve Grundy,Director of Parachute Consultancy Services Ltd

  • Reports are always well presented and timely. They maintain the highest standards of the profession and provide good value for money. Our Trustees have the highest level of confidence in their dealings with thecompany and its staff.....

    Keith Stapleford, Charity Treasurer of Gladstone Connect Limited

  • I have been a client for 10 yearís now, and I find AE Finance Ltd good value for money. The firm provides strategies on forward planning covering accountancy and taxation for both personal and business issues

    Ian Lockhart, Managing Director of GL Developments (Peterborough) Ltd

  • Their knowledge and expertise in tax and business is second to none and I would say that they have been and will continue to be the anchor point for my business.

    Steve Panton, Sole trader, Building & Brickwork Contractor

  • I was impressed by their timely and efficient service, delivered at a reasonable cost as agreed. My affairs were soon up to date! Itís always nice to have a recommendation for good professional service.

    Katherine Emma Leakey

Sign up to our free newsletter

  • Book a Free Consultation
  • Get a Fixed Quote

Request a Callback

Find out how to Make more, Keep more and Work less

Call us today
0800 678 1988

Outside office hours
07971 480456

email: ask@aefinance.uk.com

  • Email this page to a friend
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Twitter

Tax deductions for family members' wages?

Newsletter issue - March 2018.

Many adults are likely to embrace the offer of help with technology from the younger generation! So where a child is employed in a family business to work on, say, website creation, management and social media, how can the owner make sure that their wages will be tax deductible? The recent case of Nicholson v HMRC (TC06293), in which the first tier tax tribunal examined a deduction made in sole trader's accounts for his university student son, gives us some pointers.

In this case, Mr Nicholson claimed that his son had been employed in promoting the business through internet and leaflet distribution and computer work. His wages had been calculated at a rate of £10 per hour for 15 hours per week, but unfortunately there was no evidence to support wages being paid on this basis. HMRC rejected the claim because of a lack of contemporaneous records preventing a successful reconciliation from the business bank statements.

Mr Nicholson claimed that payments to his son had been paid partly through the 'provision of goods'. He managed to identify £1,850 in cash by reference to his son's bank statements. He also substantiated a monthly direct debit of £18.51 in respect of his son's home insurance costs. However, the bulk of the claim was based on Mr Nicholson buying food and drink to help support his son at university.

The tribunal made reference to an earlier judgement in Dollar & Dollar v Lyon (HM Inspector of Taxes)[1981] CH D54 TC 459, which also involved payments to family members, and concluded that Mr Nicholson's payments were made out of 'natural parental love and affection'. There was a duality of purpose as the 'wages' had a major underlying 'private and personal' motive, and thus not for the purposes of the trade. The tribunal subsequently dismissed the appeal on the grounds that Mr Nicholson was doing nothing more than supporting his son at university.

In particular, this case highlights the importance of keeping proper records regarding the basis in which payments are to be made to children. The tribunal commented that the likelihood of a successful claim would have been increased had there been payment on a time-recorded basis, or a methodology in calculating the amount payable plus an accurate record of the hours worked. A direct link between the business account and the recipient's account would clearly be advisable.

Whilst there was no suggestion here that employing relatives is an issue in itself, the importance of paying a commercial rate for the work undertaken should be noted. The concept of 'equal pay for equal value' should help prevent a suggestion of dual purpose and thus, in turn, also help refute allegations of excessive payments to family members as a means of extracting monies from the business.

Finally, wherever payments are made to family member, legal issues such as the national minimum wage should also be borne in mind.